Stem Separation Changed What a Remix Is
Pulling a clean vocal out of a finished mix used to be impossible. Now it takes seconds, and the consequences are still being worked out.
For most of recorded history, a finished mix was final. The individual parts were welded together and could not be recovered. Machine-learning separation has undone that, and the implications reach a long way past remixing.
You can listen to our full playlist which contains the artist’s music, and know more about the artist’s work by scrolling down the page.
PLAYLIST
Separation tools take a stereo mix and output approximate stems – vocals, drums, bass, other. The quality is now good enough for practical use, and where it fails it fails in characteristic ways: reverb tails smear, and sounds that overlap heavily in frequency bleed into each other. It is a reconstruction rather than a recovery, but for a great many purposes it is sufficient.
The obvious beneficiaries are remixers and DJs. Previously a remix required official stems, which meant a relationship with a label. Now anyone can extract a usable vocal from a released track, which has collapsed the barrier between official and unofficial remixing and produced an enormous amount of work that exists entirely outside the licensing system.
The less obvious use is restoration and reissue. Catalogue recordings whose multitracks were lost or destroyed can be separated and remixed, which has already produced credible new mixes of records that were previously stuck with whatever the original engineer committed to. For archival work this is genuinely transformative.
It also creates problems nobody has settled. A separated vocal is a derivative of a copyrighted recording, and extracting it is trivially easy and effectively undetectable. The same tool that enables a legitimate reissue enables an unlicensed acappella to circulate within hours of release. Rights frameworks were written on the assumption that a mix was a sealed object, and that assumption no longer holds.
For artists the practical implication is worth internalising. Anything released can be taken apart. That is not a reason to release less, but it does mean the finished mix is no longer the last decision – it is one version of an arrangement that other people can now open.
