christmas song 2024

Randie O’Neil Turns The Elf on the Shelf on the Grown-Ups in What Do You Say, Santa

An Americana Holiday Single Asks if the Grown-Ups at the Party Make the Nice List

A small elf sits on a shelf at a holiday party, watching. In What Do You Say, Santa, Randie O’Neil turns that gaze on the adults. Think clinking glasses, doubtful dance moves and guests who would not pass a naughty-or-nice check. The Americana single came out on 1 November 2024. Now the party season is starting again, and it is back with its question for Santa.

Randie O’Neil is in the playlist below with What Do You Say, Santa, a holiday single for the grown-ups. It reached this desk through PopHits.Co Music Charts, which verifies independent artists and places their releases across its network of music news sites. Press play, then read on for the story behind the elf.


Randie O'Neil Turns The Elf on the Shelf on the Grown-Ups in What Do You Say, Santa
Randie O’Neil Turns The Elf on the Shelf on the Grown-Ups in What Do You Say, Santa

What Do You Say, Santa by Randie O’Neil Arrives as the Elf on the Shelf Season Begins

The elf has a short history. The Elf on the Shelf began as a 2005 children’s book by Carol Aebersold and her daughter Chanda Bell. It grew out of a tradition from Aebersold’s own childhood. In the story, Santa sends the elf to watch how children behave. Families play along as if it really is watching, and it has since become part of Christmas across North America.

O’Neil keeps the elf and changes the suspects. The song imagines the grown-ups held to the same rules as the children, so the party becomes the test. That is the joke, and it lands because almost everyone has been to that party.

Holiday songs also have a habit of coming back. Brenda Lee recorded Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree in 1958. In December 2023 it finally topped the US Billboard Hot 100, 65 years after its release. What Do You Say, Santa did a smaller version of the same thing. A year after it came out, it climbed to number four on the Radio Indie Alliance Top 100. That was the week of 8 December 2025.

Randie O’Neil Built What Do You Say, Santa on Acoustic Guitar, Jingle Bells and a Wink

The record is short and bright. It runs to two minutes and 57 seconds. Acoustic guitar and light percussion carry it, and a touch of jingle bells keeps it festive without going over the top. The Other Side Reviews heard it as an Americana and folk-pop song with a cheeky streak, and that is fair.

Randie O’Neil wrote the words and music and sings the lead. Tom Gioia produced the record, and Lujan Carter Dent and Jennifer Douglas Foote sing the backing parts. The single came with an official music video, too.

Comic Christmas songs have a long country history. Elmo and Patsy released Grandma Got Run Over by a Reindeer in 1979. Randy Brooks wrote the novelty song, and Elmo Shropshire performed it with his then-wife, Patsy Trigg. What Do You Say, Santa belongs to that family. Its humour is gentler, though, and aimed at the adults in the room.

Watch the video and check the artist’s YouTube channel for more.
Randie O'Neil Turns The Elf on the Shelf on the Grown-Ups in What Do You Say, Santa
Randie O’Neil Turns The Elf on the Shelf on the Grown-Ups in What Do You Say, Santa

The Answer Randie O’Neil Gives in What Do You Say, Santa, and Where She Goes Next

The title asks a question, and the song answers a gap in most holiday playlists. There are plenty of songs for children and plenty of sad songs for the season. Still, there are far fewer for the grown-ups at the party, with a sense of humour about themselves.

O’Neil is an award-winning songwriter, and her work as an adolescent intervention specialist gives her lyrics a real-world eye. She has released music independently for more than a decade. Her EPs run from Woman I Am in 2017 to Heart and Soul in 2024. She also wrote an earlier holiday single, Holiday to Remember, in 2019.

The run has kept going since Santa. These Walls came out in 2025, and That Smile (no no song) followed in September. Her newest single, Ghost of Me, arrived in October 2026.

What Do You Say, Santa suits listeners who want a holiday song with a grin. It is also for anyone who has wondered what the elf would report about the office party. Start with the video, then add it to the season’s playlist.

From the NewMusic.News curator team: “We added What Do You Say, Santa to our Folk, Contemporary Folk, Chamber Folk playlist for its storytelling. It brings a folk writer’s eye to a party song, and few holiday tracks are written for the grown-ups.”

Stream the Single and Follow Her on Spotify, Instagram and Facebook

Stream What Do You Say, Santa on Apple Music. Then follow Randie O’Neil on Spotify, Apple Music, Instagram, Facebook and X.


Truth303 on the Study-Beat Era and the Making of Lo-Fi and Feels 2

Truth303 on the Study-Beat Era and the Making of Lo-Fi and Feels 2

An American Hip-Hop Artist Gathers Three Years of Singles and One New Song On 9 October 2026, three days after…

Belz Gives the Situationship a Yacht-Rock Groove on Make Up Your Mind, the First Single of Eight

Belz Gives the Situationship a Yacht-Rock Groove on Make Up Your Mind, the First Single of Eight

An American Pop Singer Sets the Undefined Romance of the Moment to Stacked Harmonies Make Up Your Mind begins in…

Radie Peat Made Her Solo Debut the Way Mike Oldfield Made Tubular Bells

Radie Peat Made Her Solo Debut the Way Mike Oldfield Made Tubular Bells

The Long Way to The Fall: Why Ruby and Resin Started Their Single Again

The Long Way to The Fall: Why Ruby and Resin Started Their Single Again

Michael Kiwanuka Finished FUDGE Before a Stroke Put It on Hold

Michael Kiwanuka Finished FUDGE Before a Stroke Put It on Hold

ANTHEM by CMONEY Ended Seven Months Without a Single, in 97 Seconds of Self-Produced Rap

ANTHEM by CMONEY Ended Seven Months Without a Single, in 97 Seconds of Self-Produced Rap

Inside All in Vain: How Aces Low Built a Nu Metal Breakup Song Over Discord

Inside All in Vain: How Aces Low Built a Nu Metal Breakup Song Over Discord

Of Your Touch by Zhenyok Chem Brat, Revisited as Lay Your Heart Down Follows Two Years Later

Of Your Touch by Zhenyok Chem Brat, Revisited as Lay Your Heart Down Follows Two Years Later

Saturn Spiders on Romantic Rock, Lou Reed and the Making of Sweet Surrender

Saturn Spiders on Romantic Rock, Lou Reed and the Making of Sweet Surrender

Phil Lentz Presents... Vol. II Arrived in Election Month, From a Star-Ledger Newsman Turned Jazz Pianist

Phil Lentz Presents… Vol. II Arrived in Election Month, From a Star-Ledger Newsman Turned Jazz Pianist

Why DIIV Let A. G. Cook Record the Drums Before the Songs Were Done

Why DIIV Let A. G. Cook Record the Drums Before the Songs Were Done

The Long Way to Eileen The Weary Crow: Beyond The Veil Follow Bloodborne's Hunter of Hunters

The Long Way to Eileen The Weary Crow: Beyond The Veil Follow Bloodborne’s Hunter of Hunters

Stockhausen's Wishes, Passed Through Ellen Corver, Shape Pedro G. A. Aguinagalderomalde's Klavierstück IX

Stockhausen’s Wishes, Passed Through Ellen Corver, Shape Pedro G. A. Aguinagalderomalde’s Klavierstück IX

Inside Time Is Wasting Away: How Rise Up Revival Built Their Longest Song Around One Question

Inside Time Is Wasting Away: How Rise Up Revival Built Their Longest Song Around One Question